My Auntie says “Why Didn’t You” Over and Over

Ask the Doctor

As I help my mom's sister and her husband get my 88-year-old uncle (my mom's single brother who helped me care for my mother when she had cancer) who has dementia that's not so far along that he doesn't remember basics, but advanced enough along that he can't live alone any more it has been very difficult for my auntie.

She has taken him in temporarily as we move towards having him go to a care home and she tries to care for him so well and to try and get him to help himself it's of course causing challenges. (Understandably so)

I read Frances Kakugawa's poem "I am somebody" and it resonated with me when she writes about not saying "Why didn't you?"

I hear my auntie say that over and over to her brother and it hurts my heart to see how it makes him feel. Truly, what was done or not done that should have been can't be changed. He should have, but he didn't or couldn't.

I have wanted to say something to my aunty but don't know how since she's coping the best she can and isn't healthy herself at age 80. I don't want to hurt her feelings since she really cares about him but is stretched to the limit since she's very meticulous about everything and the frustration is showing.

Do you have any suggestions on how I can gently remind her that

constantly asking him "why didn't you?" can't change anything and is making him feel defeated

and that he shuts down and doesn't even want to be in the same room as her as we clean his house of 40 years of "stuff?"

We are all stretched to our limits but for us, it's temporary. For my uncle his life is forever changed since he will have to move into a care home.

Thank you for your recommendations.


Reply: My Auntie says “Why Didn’t you?” over and over

From: Dr. Warren

Hi Kathy,
Thanks so much for taking the time and effort to reach out to me. Just the effort to do that is essential.

Your uncle has dementia and is entering a different chapter in his life with plans to move into a care home. In the meantime, your auntie is helping by having him stay with her. He has caused chaos and she is very frustrated with his “wrong way of doing things”. As a result, she’s saying “Why didn’t you” repeatedly and this has caused pain for your uncle, and for you.

I’m glad that Frances’ poem resonated with you. “Why didn’t you?” sounds like an accusation and is very hurtful. Frances also states: “both loved one and caregiver deserve compassion”

Here’s a poem that I imagined from your auntie’s point of view:

I love you but I don’t want you here.
I hate it that you have dementia
I’m 80 and I’m not healthy.
You’re upsetting my precarious life.
This and then that.
Can’t you do anything right?
I can’t take it anymore.
So, I’ll say it: “Why didn’t you??”

Can’t you see you’re driving me crazy.
I’d kick you out, but I can’t.
I’d cry but I can’t.
I know I shouldn’t but what else can I do?
So, I’ll say it again:
“Why didn’t you??”

We’re all in this together. Who knows what will happen in our own lives? Your auntie knows that “why didn’t you” is hurtful. She says it out of frustration. Dementia doesn’t just affect the patient. It affects loved ones, including you, as well.

My guess is that you know your auntie pretty well. If she’s at the end of her rope, she may not want to hear any suggestions. What’s the best way to support her? A big hug? A Thank You card? A present/flowers? A favorite activity? Letting your auntie know that you support her will bring out her best.

You can also use the approach of “framing”. When life events are chaotic, they can seem overwhelming. Being able to see a brighter future is a way of framing. Tell your Auntie that you are wishing and praying for a very nice care home placement soon. Once that’s accomplished, your uncle and your auntie will be very happy. She will have the satisfaction of knowing that she did her part for her brother.


Dr. Warren

Please add a suggestion or word of support for Kathy in the comments below.

Asking a question is easy. Just ask Dr. Warren.
I'll post questions and responses periodically but please keep confidential information confidential.

With Aloha,

[email protected]

P.S. On Tuesday November 10 at 10 AM Hawaii Time, the Alzheimer’s Association in collaboration with AARP will be presenting the topic: “Caregiver Emotional Self Defense”. I’ll be participating. It is still in the planning stage, and I’ll send out an announcement soon.


A Loving Thought

My friend Savy at Gimme A Break sent this loving thought:

Realize that Caregiving is living life in chaos mode all the time and we are not always our best selves. And that’s okay because we do what we do for love. The next time you have an opportunity, just look your aunt in the eye and tell her, “It’s ok, I understand”, then give her a big hug! Being supportive without judgement is just about the best thing you can do for a Caregiver.

We are a community of Caregivers that support one another. We are not professionals, just a bunch of Caregivers that share, laugh, cry, and talk to support one another. You are both invited to our weekly support sessions, that’s where we all hold hands (

Sending you calm,

Savy Makalena

Gimme A Break

Avoid asking “Why?”

  • When I trained doctors to be geriatricians one of my common suggestions was to avoid using the word: “Why?”
  • Trust and strong communications between a patient, family and physician are important. The question “Why did you do that?” can sound like an accusation.
  • A different way of asking is to say: “What was the reason for doing that?” or “Can you describe some more?”.   When phrased this way, the question is a request for clarification, not an accusation.
  • For people living with dementia these types of questions are often too complicated. But a truthful answer might be that the person thought his/her action was the best thing to do. Or that the person did not know what else to do.  The answer is seldom that the person intended to cause problems.
  • People living with dementia can still understand the emotional tone of “Why?”. It adds to the pain of living with the disease.


How many “Real World” Patients with Alzheimer’s Disease were similar to patients in the Aduhelm Study?

The FDA approval of a new drug (Aduhelm) for Alzheimer’s Disease has been extremely controversial. (Would you be first in line for the new Alzheimer's drug?) A recent article found that fewer than 1% of patients referred to a memory clinic would have been eligible for the Aduhelm study. There were many reasons. Some patients were too old, too frail or in poor health. Many patients had cognitive impairment that was too severe. As a result, findings from the study cannot be applied to most patients with Alzheimer’s Disease. Concerns include the possibility of less benefit and more harm.

PDF: Real World Eligibility for Aducanumab

Posted in Alzheimer's, Caregiving, Dr. Warren, Geriatrics with Aloha, Poetry and tagged , , .


  1. Why questions usually put people on the defensive rather than open-ended how & what discussions. Why questions often comes from a place of judging, not from a place of curiosity or duscussion. If you’d like to have a discussion that leads to understanding and solutions you might consider questions like:

    • I’m curious what happened first?
    • Interesting, & then what happened?
    • Thinking about it now when do you think things got off track?
    • Wow, and how were you feeling when that happened?
    • So, in the future, what do you think you’ll dovwhen something like this happens ?
    • Let’s think of a few options, just incase plan A doesn’t work. Do you have any ideas?
    • Considering how things turned out, what needs to happen next?
    • Well that sure helped me understand what happened & gave me some helpful ideas, if I’m ever in a similar situation. Is there anything we missed?

    I hope that helps.

  2. Dear Dr. Warren,

    I’m not sure what the background of her aunt is…if she’s able to read that I Am Somebody poem and get some insights as her niece did. would it work for her aunt?

    If I were to let her aunt read this poem, I would approach it this way to avoid telling her what to do, to not suggest she’s doing something wrong. Being the sole caregiver, she needs all the support. Not sure if this will work:

    “Aunty, I read this poem by a person who took care of her mother who had Alzheimer’s just like Uncle. It really helped me because sometimes I tell Uncle things that he cannot understand anymore, like Why didn’t you?” Or sometimes I ask too many questions and Uncle is not able to answer because of the disease. Can I read this poem to you?

    And I would leave a copy of one of my books…Mosaic Moon or I Am Somebody.
    When he goes into a nursing facility, it may even be a good idea to post that poem in his room for the staff.

    Here’s another poem that may help, a voice from a loved one.


    Tick Tock, Tick Tock


    Oh , oh, the test taker is here.

    Didn’t I take my SAT in high school?

    Didn’t I pass the Bar years ago?

    Why is she here?

    Here comes the test:


    What did you have for breakfast, Mom?

    How was dinner last night? What did you have?

    Tick Tock. Tick Tock.

    Oh no, what did I eat this morning?

    I need more than a second.

    Wait, wait. It’ll come.

    Tick Tock. Tick Tock.


    Worse than the Bar, worse than college finals,

    My mind aches, my heart beats.

    My words have gone hide and go seek.

    Tick Tock. Tick Tock.

    I can’t remember.

    Did John visit you yesterday?

    Tick Tock. Tick Tock.

    Did he? I can’t remember.


    I’ll close my eyes and maybe she’ll leave.

    Tick Tock. Tick Tock.

    Ah good, she’s gone.

    Who cares about what I ate.

    I’d rather take the SAT or the Bar.

    Than to be put on trial

    On things I don’t know.


    Oh, oh, another visitor.

    Oh, I like him.

    He tells me stories.

    Yesterday I laughed

    When he told me how he spilled his coffee

    All over his shirt before his meeting.

    I like the songs he sings –

    Sometimes I sing along.

    Today he’s sitting with his leg on my bed,

    Reading. That’s nice.

    I like how he smiles at me before

    He turns each page with his fingers.

    I like this silence.

    My heart is calm, there’s no test,

    It’s like being at the beach,

    Watching the waves come in.

    Ah…this is nice.

    No tick tock, tick tock

    Not even for a second.


    ©Frances Kakugawa


    Hope this helps.

    I don’t want to promote my books or my AARP session but I will be covering these topics that day.

    Take care,


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *